Florida Blue Health Plans

Bay Insurance
Bluecross Blueshield of Florida
Blue Cross Blue Shield Sarasota
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida

Local Health Insurance Agents Helping Local People

At Bay Insurance Sarasota, we can answer all your health insurance questions and offer reliable Florida health insurance quotes. We represent Florida Blue©, one of the top health insurance carriers and can offer many health plan options to suit your budget and needs. We take pride in our Florida Blue© health insurance products and our quality customer service. We believe in real relationships with our clients. Remember Bay Insurance for your healthcare insurance.

Trusted Experience and Dedicated Service

Our experienced health insurance agents are honest people serving the Sarasota and Manatee County areas. Many have been with Bay Insurance for 15 plus years and know Florida Blue© Health Insurance plans and options inside and out. They are able to the answers your health insurance questions. We are real people serving real people.

20,000 clients can't be wrong!

Bay Insurance Sarasota was formed in 1992 and has been conveniently located on Bee Ridge Road since. Manager Shirley Hicks has been with the organization for 20 years and is consistently a Florida Blue Diamond Club member and Top Achiever.

Shirley's lead by example management style has served our sales associates and customers extremely well. We have been the top producer for Florida health insurance in that area since our first year. Bay Insurance Sarasota has served over 20,000 clients throughout the Sarasota and Manatee County areas during this time.

Staff: Pat Martin, Kathie Catterlin.

Agents: Shirley Hicks, Paul Eskew, Roxanne Chevtaikin, Carol Eskew, Darleen Speers, Walter Myers, Mark Stoker, Vincent Cerrone.

Why Florida Blue© Health Insurance?

  • Locally Florida owned BCBS
  • Established reputation
  • Large network of doctors and hospitals
  • Largest selection of coverage options 100+
  • Lower premiums for amount of insurance coverage offered
  • Rated the best Health Plan in 2008 by JD Powers survey
  • Fast approval process
  • Good record of claims paid to insured
  • Competitive insurance rates
  • 7-10% yearly rate increase instead of 30-40% from other top carriers

Why Bay Insurance?

  • Lasting relationships with our clients
  • Quality health plans and flexible options
  • Affordable health plan benefits
  • Easy and convenient application process
  • Competitive insurance premiums and rates
  • Flexibility of on site applications or internet applications


Some policies may have exclusions and limitations. For costs and complete details of coverage, call or write the insurance agent. The amount of benefits and premium will vary depending upon the plan selected.

Website property of Bay Insurance ©2013, all right reserved. Phone: 1.800.330.3598
Web Design by Lone Bird Studio Asheville NC Web Design